Authentic NY-style pizza that gives you a slice of the Big Apple with a slice of pizza so wide, you gotta fold it! We pride ourselves on only using the freshest premium ingredients for our pizzas, chef-made garlic knots, cheesy bread & wings.
In July of 2011, we started off as one food truck (Manny) that wanted to bring Authentic NEW YORK PIZZA to Indianapolis. Our Food Truck and 20″ Pizzas became the talk of Indy and within 4 months of starting the business, the demand was so high that we added a second food truck (Brooklyn). Under new ownership and a CIA chef that has a history of bringing Indy authentic Four-Star pizza and Italian specialties (Eh Formaggio and da BIG Formaggio), We offer catering, carryout and delivery to Downtown & The South Side of Indianapolis.
Don’t believe dis is authentic New Yawk? OK, here ya go: Dis is da best NY Slice youse ever will have, period. Not fer nuttin’, we’re not friggin’ kiddin. Lissen, dis is really serious pizza—made by culinary professionals, capiche?
Yyou wanna try dis at home? So ax us nicely and we’ll see what we can do ‘bout bringin’ our hand-made, customized, brick-oven delights right to yer door—cuz sooner or later, we’ll know where ya live. So, call us, awreddy—what, you need an invitation?
So, tell ya what—come by da place. We’re waitin‘ fer yas in a friggin’ strip mall on da South Side on Madison Ave. Do’t be late!
Our philosophy is to keep our menu small and simple to ensure that every product on our menu is of the highest quality around. We don’t try to do everything, but make everything we do the BEST!
We never imagined that we would be able to expand 2 times in less than a year, but that’s only because of our loyal customers. We want to thank each and every one of you that has spread the word about The NY Slice and look forward to serving you for years to come.